If some get their way, auto makers will have a great excuse to boost prices even higher. As is often the case, the bills under consideration are well intentioned, but foreshadow increased costs for moderate-income people who might buy a new car.
WASHINGTON - A bipartisan bill requiring new cars to install advanced alcohol detection software was introduced on Wednesday to help prevent drunk driving.
Senators Rick Scott, R-Fla., and Tom Udall, D-N.M., introduced the Reduce Impaired Driving for Everyone (RIDE) Act of 2019, which “will promote the research and development of advanced alcohol detection software and will require the implementation of such technology in new motor vehicles,” said news releases from both senators’ offices. Representative Debbie Dingell, D-Mich., also introduced similar legislation, the HALT Drunk Driving Act, in the House of Representatives.
The goal is laudable, if simplistic, as advanced alcohol detection software would, in and of itself, do nothing. In order to function, the software will require hardware capable of detecting ambient alcohol levels in the atmosphere of the vehicle, as the bills promote passive alcohol detection:
Impaired driving crashes cause a major emotional and financial toll, including the premature deaths of children, parents, friends, and breadwinners within families. The RIDE Act addresses the urgent need to end these preventable tragedies by putting us on the fast track toward reliable passive alcohol detection technology in every new car.
As usual, should the bills pass, the law of unintended consequences comes into play: drunks will gravitate to the used vehicle markets, and will continue to get behind the wheel. Ditto for those with limited incomes, in order to avoid the increased costs associated with the addition of the technology in new vehicles. Thus, it would be a "feel-good" law that actually accomplishes little to nothing (apart from depressing the new vehicle markets).
As well, one may wonder how effective passive detection systems would be if the windows of the vehicle are rolled down.